(192 Recipes) Peanut Butter Pie Recipes

Very Good 4.9/5
(7 ratings)

Absolutely delicious - a hit with everyone in our family, dieter, diabetic or not!Submitted by: GLVS2DANCE

Very Good 4.7/5
(6 ratings)

A pie made by my daughter for her Keepers At Home class. She is 9 years old.Submitted by: JAZZERSOUTH

Incredible! 5.0/5
(3 ratings)

Delicious Freezer PieSubmitted by: **SUZY**

Very Good 4.3/5
(3 ratings)

Note that I got 10 pieces instead of the 8 that the pie crust will have on the label.
Make sure the pudding mixes are instant fat free and sugar free.

Submitted by: JESSICA0431

Incredible! 5.0/5
(2 ratings)

Submitted by: KAYMOM

Incredible! 5.0/5
(2 ratings)

Simple, quick & easy. Just a few simple ingredients and no cooking. ( Instant Pudding, Dry Milk, Peanut Butter, Cool Whip, Graham Cracker Pie Crust. ) My wife's most requested dessert.Submitted by: WEB1323

Good 3.0/5
(2 ratings)

Low Carb - Great TasteSubmitted by: CECILMILLER

Bad 1.0/5
(2 ratings)

Lower fat recipe. This no-bake recipe makes 2 pies. The pies are best served frozen.Submitted by: MAURMAUR

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: SLJGEMINI75

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: GUNIVERA

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

Nice low cal dessert optionSubmitted by: JENHILL84

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: KIKKIS

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

This is a much healthier dessert then, icecream cake or full fat pies, but fills that same gap.Submitted by: SHELLYRENEE86

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

This pie is a holiday staple in my family! My new in-laws beg me to make it for every special occasion. I realize that this is NOT considered healthy, nor is it low-calorie in any way, but I do use some swaps that help lower the fat and calories. If you've gotta have it, at least you can have it a little lighter! Just make sure to practice moderation. Submitted by: PINKYGALMISH

Incredible! 5.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: HBROAD1

Very Good 4.0/5
(1 rating)

My aunt's amazing, family favorite. So good, but so bad. 1/10 of the pie is very rich, and really--you could enjoy half a slice. But still....it's a crowd pleaser and definitely one to enjoy every once in a while. Submitted by: ELOHRMEY

Very Good 4.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: PONO-ONE

Very Good 4.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: LADYBUGTX18

Very Good 4.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: AOITONBO

Good 3.0/5
(1 rating)

made sugar-free pudding, skim milk ("over the moon" brand), natural PB, and a graham cracker crust.Submitted by: MZ_NO_ROLLS

Good 3.0/5
(1 rating)

creamy peanut butter and chocolate pieSubmitted by: KATIE541

Bad 1.0/5
(1 rating)

Submitted by: HEATHERGRENIER3

(no ratings)

6 ww points a sliceSubmitted by: MACIELP415

(no ratings)

Submitted by: ABSNYD

(no ratings)

Serves 8. VERY easy, really truly. I'm a total wuss in the kitchen. If this works for me it'll work for your six year old!Submitted by: NOIRE3

(no ratings)

A cheescake like peanut butter pie with less calories then the original!Submitted by: ANWYNS

(no ratings)

This pie is far from low-fat or low-cal, but is delicious! It's a family recipe from Thanksgivings as a kid. I remember doing it by hand (before electric mixers) with a whisk. Much easier these days! With this recipe, a little bit goes a long way - it is a very rich dessert!Submitted by: SPORTSFANRG

(no ratings)

Delicious alternative to restaurant peanut butter cup pie. Can use different flavor pudding on top, add whip cream or cool whip, add chocolate chips.....Submitted by: MAL147

(no ratings)

Reduced Fat/ Reduced Sudar
Delicious DessertSubmitted by: MREBECCADW

(no ratings)

Submitted by: YOCUM3

(no ratings)

Submitted by: DONNETTASUE

(no ratings)

Delicious. Tastes like a Butterfinger, only smooth.Submitted by: SWEETPEAPIG1980

(no ratings)

Submitted by: GRANDBRAT

(no ratings)

My husband's favorite summer-time pie ; I lightned it up by using low-fat cream cheese, 1% milk and light Cool Whip and cutting sugar by 1/3.Submitted by: SOCAL_MICHELLE

(no ratings)

Submitted by: SAMGRAVES1800

(no ratings)

Super rich with a creamy texture, this is NOT a low cal food! I was served this cheesecake-like pie recently and decided to get the recipe in case I ever want to splurge on my calories! Original recipe says that this is 10-12 servings, but 1/16 slices are plenty because of its incredible richness.Submitted by: FDOODLES

(no ratings)

Submitted by: RUPERTSWIFE

(no ratings)

Submitted by: CMROACH

(no ratings)

Not the greatest for you but so addicting. A definite crowd pleaser. And this recipe makes 3 pies!Submitted by: MUSICALMOMMAKAT

(no ratings)

Make 16 servings, graham crust is extra servings crust (larger than standard graham cracker crust)Submitted by: KERRMOORKELLY

(no ratings)

low fat version for nutrition courseSubmitted by: CARRIELYNNG

(no ratings)

If you are a lover of peanut butter cheesecake, but trying to watch your calories, then you are going to love this one because you can have your pie and eat it, too!Submitted by: TEXASNANA4

(no ratings)

This is a lighter version but still very enjoyableSubmitted by: SCRAPPYGRAMMY

(no ratings)

Submitted by: CJSWAGER

(no ratings)

So easy and sooooo yummy!Submitted by: NANI031

(no ratings)

A very easy and super delicious vegan no-bake peanut butter pie!Submitted by: VIAGGIATRICE

(no ratings)

Recipe Courtesy www.sugarfreesheila.comSubmitted by: APHRODITEXOXO

(no ratings)

Submitted by: BUGGABOOSMAMA

(no ratings)

This is a deliciously wicked dessert - not one you want to have often, but worth the extra calories for something special.Submitted by: SCRAPPYGRAMMY

(no ratings)

Submitted by: LUV-BEING-NANA