Holiday Spice Cut-Out Cookies

(43)
  • Minutes to Prepare:
  • Minutes to Cook:
  • Number of Servings: 60
Ingredients
1 cup I Can't Believe It's Not Butter baking blend1/2 cup organic cane sugar1/4 cup molasses1/4 cup orange juice1 1/2 tsp cinnamon,ground2 tsp ginger, ground1 tsp allspice3 cups whole wheat flourCreamy Decorator's Frosting:1 cup powdered sugar1/2 tsp vanilla extract1-2 Tbsp skim milkFew drops of food coloring, as desired
Directions
Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

Beat the butter blend using a mixer until softened. Add sugar and beat until smooth. Add molasses and orange juice and blend. Mix the flour with the spices and then add to wet mixture. Stir until dough is formed.

You may roll out dough at this point, but the whole wheat flour will absorb the liquid from the orange juice and blend the flavors better if let to chill for 30 minutes.

Divide the dough in half and roll one half to 1/8 inch thickness. Flour the cutter and cut out the cookies. Place on cookie sheet that has been lined with parchment paper or use silicone baking sheet liners. These will not spread much so they can be placed about 1/2 inch apart.

In order to assure a more evenly baked cookie, place one cookie sheet on the upper third of the oven rack and the other cookie sheet on the lower third oven rack. Bake for 5 minutes and then shift positions, and turn cookie sheets front to back. Bake another 5 minutes. Cool on rack. Be sure to cool completely before decorating.

Yield: 5 dozen 2-2/2 inch cut-out cookies

For the frosting:
Mix all ingredients in small bowl until the mixture is smooth and easy to spread. Add more milk if needed.


Servings Per Recipe: 60
Nutritional Info Amount Per Serving
  • Calories: 66.7
  • Total Fat: 3.1 g
  • Cholesterol: 0.0 mg
  • Sodium: 26.4 mg
  • Total Carbs: 9.4 g
  • Dietary Fiber: 0.8 g
  • Protein: 0.9 g

Member Reviews
  • KATIBUG98
    Couple of things. #1-I used light butter/light stick margarine in place of the ICBINB as it's lower in calories/fat. #2-I've used both Splenda and regular sugar *and a combination* and they were fine. #3-I added 1/2tsp of baking soda & 1/2tsp salt as otherwise they wouldn't rise. My kids ♥ th - 12/16/10
  • NMLAHAIE
    Even with extra spice (cinnamon and pumpkin pie), my cookies ended up looking and tasting like slightly sweet wheat thins. They sound nice but I won't be making them again. - 12/12/09
  • ASTALANYA
    I use Kool-Aid (sugar-free if I can find it) for colour and flavour to my icing. - 12/13/11
  • MICHELLEK186
    I didn't use the ICBINB baking blend, just a light version, whole wheat flour, or the organic sugar, and they still turned out nice. I did not, however, like the icing - way too sweet and not the right consistency unless I added more sugar. Sans icing, they were a hit at xmas! - 1/3/10
  • CD5236037
    unfortunately my daughter and I tried this recipe, and found the cookie was a good consistency, but the flavor was....not good. We thought the batter tasted good though! I wish it suited us better, but it just didn't work for us. - 12/5/13
  • EVILKLOWN
    "Organic" sugar? Uh, no ty. - 12/4/13
  • JUNEBUGT
    Watch the heat and time in the oven. thickness makes a big difference- make sure each cookie is the same size. I made 4" gingerbread men. I added the 1/2 tsp baking soda and salt and used the Spllenda brown sugar. Taste good - 12/14/12
  • GREASE31
    I luv this recipe, it sounds just perfect. - 12/14/12
  • PATRICIAANN46
    I have made this recipe many times and it is a hit every time. Thanks. - 12/6/12
  • CD3409143
    I love molasses cookies - 12/11/11
  • LEANJEAN6
    Easy to make and very tasty-- - 12/11/11
  • _TRIXIE_
    With what I have at home, can I use regular unsalted stick butter? I'd rather not have to buy the specific items, if possible. Also, can I use Splenda instead of cane sugar? - 12/11/09
  • WOWEETOO
    this is an excelent cookie deal if you are diabetic for sure!! yummy - 12/11/09
  • GEORGE815
    Nice recipe - 12/23/20
  • TERMITEMOM
    These are great. I did not frost them. - 12/10/20
  • PWILLOW1
    Wow, these were wonderful. I did add 1/2 tsp. baking powder & 1/2 tsp. salt as KATIBUG98 suggested. - 12/10/20
  • 4CONNIESHEALTH
    Good recipe. I should have followed some of the other peoples comments. - 12/8/20
  • CD6913562
    Excellent cookies! - 12/8/20
  • RAPUNZEL53
    Lovely - 11/19/20
  • PICKIE98
    I may try a half batch at first.. - 7/14/20
  • NASFKAB
    Great idea - 3/22/20
  • LOSER05
    yum - 3/16/20
  • JIACOLO
    I don't make cookies too often anymore, but these seem easy enough. - 3/16/20
  • SUNSHINE99999
    Great! - 12/23/19
  • CD3802882
    These were great! I added a pinch of clove to make them more spicy! Yum! - 12/22/19