Butternut Squash Pie (Sweet Potato Pie Substitute)


4.8 of 5 (4)
member ratings
Nutritional Info
  • Servings Per Recipe: 6
  • Amount Per Serving
  • Calories: 56.0
  • Total Fat: 0.2 g
  • Cholesterol: 0.0 mg
  • Sodium: 356.8 mg
  • Total Carbs: 13.5 g
  • Dietary Fiber: 0.3 g
  • Protein: 3.1 g

View full nutritional breakdown of Butternut Squash Pie (Sweet Potato Pie Substitute) calories by ingredient


Introduction

A recipe I found in Hungry-Girl cookbook. It's delicious! I didn't add the marshmallows on the top and it was still good. If you do add marshmallows, be sure to include in your count. A recipe I found in Hungry-Girl cookbook. It's delicious! I didn't add the marshmallows on the top and it was still good. If you do add marshmallows, be sure to include in your count.
Number of Servings: 6

Ingredients

    1 large Butternut Squash
    1/2 cup liquid egg whites
    1/3 cup Silk, Light Vanilla Soymilk
    1/3 cup Maple Grove Sugar Free Syrup
    1/4 cup Splenda
    1 tsp Cinnamon
    1/2 tsp Vanilla Extract
    1/4 tsp Salt

Directions

Use a sharp knife to remove both ends of the squash. Peel squash and cut into large chunks, removing seeds.

Fill a large, microwave-safe dish with 1/2 inch of water. Place squash into the dish and cover. Microwave for about 8-10 minutes and then drain (squash should be tender enough to mash, but not overcooked).

With a potato masher, food processor, or fork, mash squash thoroughly. Measure out 2 generous cups, lightly packed, and place in a baking dish.

Add all ingredients to the dish. Mix ingredients thoroughly, but do not over stir (squash should still be pulpy). Bake in the oven for 45-50 minutes, until solid and not liquidy.

**Pie may be topped with 2/3 cup of mini marshmallows and baked for an additional 5 minutes, but be sure to add these into your calorie count!

Number of Servings: 6

Recipe submitted by SparkPeople user DEBSZI.

Member Ratings For This Recipe


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    1 of 1 people found this review helpful
    This was great! I added a tiny bit of ginger and cake spice too! and a tad bit extra vanilla!
    My Hubbie and I ate the whole thing!
    :)
    - 11/24/10


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    This was really good. Added a little nutmeg to mine. Hubby just loved it. My son went crazy for it. - 7/22/21


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Awesome! Light and airy dessert! Sliced squash lengthwise, removed seeds and baked for about 45 min. in pan with some water, then just scooped out the meat when it cooled. - 12/26/10


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    I really liked this and made it for thanksgiving. My family likes the traditional sweet potato bake with struesel topping but were happy with this lighter version. - 11/29/10


  • no profile photo


    I made a butternut squash pie this evening. But I did not follow this recipe exactly, but it was very good. I think as good as pumpkin. I will be making this again for sure! - 3/10/10