Chocolate Ice Cream-Peanut Butter Pie

(18)
  • Minutes to Prepare:
  • Number of Servings: 12
Ingredients
1 Carton Breyer's Chocolate Fudge No Sugar Added Ice Cream1/2 Cup Reduced Fat Creamy Peanut Butter1 Box 100 Calorie Oreo Cookies2 Tbsp Smart Balance Margarine, Melted
Directions
For Pie Crust:
In a medium bowl crush the contents of entire box of 100 calorie packs into crumbs.
Drizzle melted margarine over cookie crumbs. Mix well, distributing margarine through crumbs.
Put mixture into a pie pan lightly sprayed with pan spray. Using a plastic bag over your hand, press the mixture into the bottom and up the sides of the pie pan.
Refridgerate for at least 1 hour.

For Filling:
Place entire carton of ice cream in a large bowl. Let stand at room temperature until soft.
Drop peanut butter by tablespoons over ice cream.
Swirl peanut butter throughout ice cream.
Spoon ice cream-peanut butter mixture into pie crust, careful to not disturb cookie crust, mounding as necessary.
Freeze for at least one hour.

Optional:
Prior to freezing pie, drizzle heated Smuckers Sugar Free Hot Fudge Topping over the top of pie.

Calorie Count:
If pie is cut into 10 pieces, 224 calories per slice.
If pie is cut into 12 pieces, 187 calories per slice.

Number of Servings: 12

Recipe submitted by SparkPeople user GLVS2DANCE.

Servings Per Recipe: 12
Nutritional Info Amount Per Serving
  • Calories: 186.6
  • Total Fat: 2.7 g
  • Cholesterol: 0.0 mg
  • Sodium: 108.3 mg
  • Total Carbs: 9.5 g
  • Dietary Fiber: 0.5 g
  • Protein: 0.5 g

Member Reviews
  • CLAWFRANK
    Save time by using a pre-made oreo crust. Gives it a few more calories but is worth it to me. - 7/24/11
  • REGINAROLLINS
    Didn't think this was gonna be that good but it was a big hit with all-YUMMY and refreshing too!!!! - 7/3/14
  • JIFFMOM
    My family thought this was a "pretty good" pie. - 11/19/10
  • CSQURRED
    This was delicious, very rich - 10/5/09
  • KJCAMPERS
    I made this for a 4th of July picnic...everyone loved it!! - 7/8/09

    Reply from GLVS2DANCE (7/8/09)
    Thank you! It's my son's favorite dessert now & he doesn't even need to diet. :o)

  • BIKE4HEALTH
    thanks - 6/8/21
  • ELRIDDICK
    Thanks for sharing - 8/23/20
  • CHERYLHURT
    Great - 3/31/20
  • JANTHEBLONDE
    I love this chocolate ice cream peanut butter pie recipe! Yummy1 - 2/20/20
  • 4CONNIESHEALTH
    This is good but not as good as I had wanted for the calories. - 1/16/20
  • MUSICNUT
    So tasty! - 6/5/19
  • BONDMANUS2002
    Yumm - 5/4/19
  • ROSSYFLOSSY
    So rich and delicious . - 3/11/19
  • REDROBIN47
    OMGosh. This is to die for. I'll make this often when we have company. - 2/13/19
  • PATRICIAANN46
    This is absolutely delicious.............Thank You. - 12/13/18
  • CD3802882
    This is so good! - 12/10/18
  • BYWAYOFTHEMUSE
    I'm so happy I found this! I've been missing all the rich desserts since becoming Diabetic. Finding recipes like this gives me hope! :) - 11/19/18
  • DMEYER4
    this is awesome - 4/21/17
  • CHERIRIDDELL
    I used frozen lowfat yogurt for even fewer calories - 1/27/17
  • CD13400443
    my mom like it me a litter my mom said it to dri for. - 12/13/12
  • CATHYR70
    great recipe for my card group! - 9/8/11
  • MAMASAN007
    Made this for Father's Day since both my father and husband are diabetic. Everyone LOVED it! - 6/20/11
  • JAZZERCISEGENIE
    going to try this definitely - 7/28/09