Peppercorn Steak with Herbed Blue Cheese

(74)
  • Minutes to Prepare:
  • Minutes to Cook:
  • Number of Servings: 4
Ingredients
3 tbsp crumbled blue cheese1⁄4 cup chopped parsley (1⁄3 of a bunch)2 tsp of black, red, and pink peppercorns,cracked (see Note)1 beef fillet (12 ounces), cut into 3-ouncesteaks
Directions
1. Preheat the oven to 375° F. In a small bowl, combine the blue cheese and parsley and use a wooden spoon to loosely work into a paste. Cover and refrigerate.
2. Spread the cracked peppercorns onto a plate. Pat the meat dry and roll in the peppercorns to coat on all sides.
3. Place a cast-iron skillet or heavy-bottomed ovenproof sauté pan over moderately high heat. (Do not use nonstick cooking spray or any type of oil to prepare the pan.) Once hot, place steaks into the dry pan and sear the top and bottom of each steak (see Note), 1 to 2 minutes per side.
4. Place 1 tablespoon of the blue cheese mixture on top of each steak and transfer the pan to the oven. Roast 6 to 7 minutes for rare, 7 to 8 minutes for medium.

Note: To crack whole peppercorns, pour the desired amount into a sturdy plastic bag and then spread them flat on a dish towel or cutting board (to protect your counter top). Then, with the smooth side of a meat mallet, a rolling pan, or the bottom
of a heavy pan, pound the peppercorns into a very
coarse grind.

When searing a steak (or any meat), you want to achieve a nice, crispy, well-caramelized crust. To do so, don’t be tempted to pull the meat from the pan’s surface too early. The meat will release
easily once completely seared; any resistance and it’s not done yet.

Servings Per Recipe: 4
Nutritional Info Amount Per Serving
  • Calories: 245.8
  • Total Fat: 18.2 g
  • Cholesterol: 65.3 mg
  • Sodium: 159.1 mg
  • Total Carbs: 1.2 g
  • Dietary Fiber: 0.4 g
  • Protein: 18.5 g

Member Reviews
  • CD12520042
    I only gave this 3 stars, not for the taste which is delicious, but for the serving size. This shouldn't even have been included in a diet menu. It's like taking one bite of pizza and then walking away. Serve a 5-6 oz portion for a special occasion with a salad & asparagus - 6/6/12
  • DREAMMAKER203
    Of course this is fabulous BUT how do you put 1 tbsp of crumbled bleu cheese per serving (4 servings) and only have 3 tbsps of crumbled bleu cheese in the entire recipe? Does that mean all these nutrition counts are off? LET'S BE CAREFUL FOLKS. - 1/12/12

    Reply from SPCOOKBOOK (1/12/12)
    You're correct. We used three tablespoons of blue cheese, but then we add to it a quarter cup of chopped parsley. They final volume for the HERBED blue cheese is four tablespoons or so. That nutrition info is correct.

  • L.I.L.MOMMY
    lstouch, a "normal" serving size of beef is 3 oz. I know this seems small to those of us who are used to eating too much food and are overweight. But it's what a true portion size should be! - 10/29/12
  • MIRANDA2112
    Great simple recipe! Had no Bleu cheese handy and used Feta, results were so filling and satisfying - 3/20/12
  • LESLIECOY
    Our Valentine's Night Dinner !This was AWESOME ! My hubby does not like Blue Cheese and he even declared this a keeper ! Served with oven roasted asparagus (Olive Oil- Garlic- 450 degree oven)and Oven Roasted Petite Lobster Tails (Butter Spray). Steak in the oven 7min- Rare. It was a Celebration ! - 2/15/12
  • CD12374983
    Great recipe. I think I would have sliced the meat and showed it that way in the photo since it is supposed to feed four people. Slicing meat like this in thin slices cut at an angle helps to give you visually a "larger portion" signal. - 5/11/12
  • FLOWERDALEJEWEL
    I agree with LSTOUCH, the taste is delicious, but 85 grams (or 3oz) of steak doesn't even count as a serve of steak 120 grams (4.5 oz) would be a more satisfying size with a minimal increase in calories. - 12/7/14
  • VIKYLEE1
    Could do without the bleu cheese. Otherwise...top notch. - 1/14/12
  • CD13006718
    We did ours on the grill. Seared the steaks first, then added the blue cheese mixture. They were fantastic! - 9/3/12
  • DIANAL82
    I have cealic disease and I am always having problems finding food to eat but this recipe is great and very fulfulling - 9/13/11
  • CECTARR
    3 oz of steak is not real. I'd rather have the lean portion of a steak than any blue cheese. Steak is protein and not all cuts are as fat as the other - 3/5/20
  • SHERYE
    My family and I are not big fan's of bleu cheese so I used swiss cheese, it was really good - 12/7/19
  • CKEYES1
    Not a blue cheese fan. Maybe feta? - 12/7/19
  • JIACOLO
    I am not one for needing something on top of my steak, but this looks good - 12/7/19
  • SUSANBEAMON
    Good. I don't often cook meat, so this was very good. - 9/12/19
  • RO2BENT
    probably good if you like blue cheese - 11/27/18
  • USMAWIFE
    i had it no cheese - 2/22/18
  • TOMATOCAFEGAL
    need a good piece of meat, then this will work. - 12/8/17
  • REDROBIN47
    This looks awesome to me but DH won't eat blue cheese. - 12/7/17
  • JAMER123
    Not a blue cheese fan but love the steak. - 12/7/17
  • ADRIENALINE
    Not a beef or a blue cheese fan. Not my recipe - 12/7/17
  • JOHNMARTINMILES
    I will try it without the bleu cheese which is one of my don't eat it foods! - 12/7/17
  • RHOOK20047
    I like easy but I don't like blue cheese, so I left it off. - 12/7/17
  • KITT52
    Did not like the topping .. use a pepper mill to crack the pepper. - 5/6/17
  • CTYONIT
    I make something similar but use feta cheese because I don't like blue cheese. - 3/17/17