Cottage Pie

Cottage Pie

4 of 5 (95)
member ratings
Nutritional Info
  • Servings Per Recipe: 4
  • Amount Per Serving
  • Calories: 271.3
  • Total Fat: 4.8 g
  • Cholesterol: 100.0 mg
  • Sodium: 309.0 mg
  • Total Carbs: 35.7 g
  • Dietary Fiber: 6.9 g
  • Protein: 23.4 g

View full nutritional breakdown of Cottage Pie calories by ingredient


Introduction

Just like Chef Meg's mom (who was from Britain) used to make! Just like Chef Meg's mom (who was from Britain) used to make!
Number of Servings: 4

Ingredients

    Potato Topping:
    2 russet potatoes, peeled and diced
    1/4 teaspoon salt
    1 egg yolk

    Filling:
    12 ounces lean beef, 96% lean
    1 cup onions, diced
    1/2 teaspoon black pepper
    1 teaspoon thyme, dried
    1 teaspoon chili powder
    2 cups carrots, shredded
    1 cup fresh green beans, chopped
    1/2 cup frozen corn
    2 tablespoons tomato paste
    1 cup low-sodium vegetable or chicken stock

Tips

Cottage pie and shepherd's pie are popular British meals. What's the difference? Both contain meat and vegetables and are topped with mashed potatoes; however, cottage pie contains beef, and shepherd's pie contains lamb. I like them both!

To keep the lean beef from sticking to the pan, I cook the beef and onions at the same time.

I prefer to use French-cut green beans in this recipe.

For a vegetarian version, use soy crumbles or cooked lentils and vegetable broth.


Directions

Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit.

Place the potatoes in a medium saucepan, then cover with cold water. Cover the pot with a lid, bring to a boil and then reduce to a simmer. Cook for 10-12 minutes, until the potatoes are soft.

While potatoes are simmering, prepare the filling. Place a large saute pan over moderate heat, add the beef and onions, and cook until the beef is no longer pink. Add the carrots, beans, spices, and tomato paste, stir to combine, and simmer for 2-3 minutes. Add the stock and corn, then stir to combine. Place the meat and vegetables into a casserole dish and set aside.

Drain the potatoes and mash well, using a potato masher or ricer. Add the egg yolk and salt. Spread or pipe on top of the meat mixture. Bake 10 minutes, until the potatoes are browned.
Serves 4.


Member Ratings For This Recipe


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    38 of 48 people found this review helpful
    Edible, but--in my grandmother's recipe (granddad was Irish, she was German) she used any veggies in season or that she herself had canned. The chili powder is not traditional, I don't like it in this. And the filling was runny, she added 2 Tbsp flour to thicken so it stands up the way other pies do - 3/25/11


  • no profile photo


    32 of 48 people found this review helpful
    I find the recipes on here very hard to deal with cuz the servings are listed as 8 servings, 4 servings etc. So how big is a serving? Is it a cup or what? How about giving it in weight or a measuring size of some sort, like a cup or 8 ounces? - 10/26/11


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    32 of 34 people found this review helpful
    I went vegetarian with this using lentils to replace the meat and added mashed cauliflower to the potatoes for more potato taste, without all the calories....YUM! - 3/25/11


  • no profile photo


    19 of 19 people found this review helpful
    My DH and I were very pleased witht his recipe! I used lowfat milk in the potatoes-about 1/4 cup instead of the egg. I also cooked the filling until the broth was almost absorbed so it wouldn't be runny. Used black pepper instead of chili powder. It's a keeper! - 11/7/11


  • no profile photo


    16 of 21 people found this review helpful
    Variations - a tin of chopped tomato (with nothing added) or a jar of tomato passata (nothing added).
    Reduce the GI,mix the potato with carrot and turnip, or cauliflower. Use skim milk instead of egg yolk.
    Less work:a pack of frozen veg (diced carrot, sweetcorn, peas). Or just frozen peas.
    No chi
    - 3/25/11


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    13 of 13 people found this review helpful
    Great comfort food, thanks for the recipe, personally I added some chopped garlic in the sautee part, but then I put garlic in most everything - 7/3/11


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    9 of 10 people found this review helpful
    Yum! Just had this for dinner - it was GREAT! I used some green onions and celery in addition to the ingredients suggested above. Also used chicken stock vs milk/butter to make the mashed potatoes. Super delicious! Whether traditional or not it was healthy and tasty...thanks Meg! - 9/22/11


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    5 of 6 people found this review helpful
    This was very good - I agree with others that more veggies are good and the idea of puree-ing them to thicken the meat mixture is definitely one I will try. In the UK this is often made on Mondays with minced beef/lamb from Sunday's roast as a way to use leftovers. - 9/12/11


  • no profile photo


    5 of 6 people found this review helpful
    I have a somewhat similar version but I use extra lean ground turkey breast. For the vegs. I just use frozen mixed veg. (sometimes brocolli and carrots) and run under hot water just to thaw. Layer cooked turkey, vegs, sliced (lengthwise) string cheese, and top with smashed red potato (with skins). - 3/25/11


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    4 of 4 people found this review helpful
    This was really quite delicious! I added some grated cheese and a sprinkle of breadcrumbs to the top for flavour and so that it would brown up nicely in the oven, and I omitted the black pepper and chilli powder, adding fresh garlic instead. - 1/31/12


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    4 of 4 people found this review helpful
    Made this yesterday, it was very good. I had some leftovers for lunch today and it's GREAT the second day! I did sub low fat chicken sausage for the beef since I had an open package, but everything meshed together so well, the flavors and texture are great! This will become a go-to recipe fore sure! - 11/14/11


  • no profile photo


    2 of 4 people found this review helpful
    Made me chuckle, I seen cottage pie and thought cottage cheese and since I just bought some, thought I was in for a treat. lol

    This does look good, though!
    - 4/5/12


  • no profile photo


    2 of 5 people found this review helpful
    im definitely going to be trying this one. i <3 shepherds pie - 3/24/11


  • no profile photo


    1 of 3 people found this review helpful
    It is nothing like a British recipe - except in name.
    We use ground beef (minced beef).
    - 4/6/12


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    1 of 1 people found this review helpful
    Just finished cooking and smells delicious. Was really easy make, and makes 4 HUGE servings. I split into two smaller casserole dishes and froze one. Will probably end up with 6 to 8 servings. - 3/12/12


  • no profile photo


    1 of 2 people found this review helpful
    More traditional without the chili powder and corn! - 2/19/12


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    1 of 2 people found this review helpful
    I made this two nights ago. My husband & I really enjoyed it. I didn't have the carrots so I used 2 cups of frozen mixed veggies (carrots, peas and corn). I cooked it on the stove in my cast iron skillet, then just added the mashed potatoes on top and put it in the oven. I will make this again! - 2/18/12


  • no profile photo


    1 of 3 people found this review helpful
    Use cauliflower mashed on top instead of potatoes to be extra healthy and doesnt spoil the taste - 1/28/12


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    1 of 5 people found this review helpful
    This recipe looks like a winner a healthy pot pie. - 1/5/12


  • no profile photo


    1 of 3 people found this review helpful
    I made this for dinner the other night. It was fantastic! My coen wasn't frozen, it was cut from the cob fresh for corn chowder I made the night before. (leftover...another yummy dinner!) My husband was shelling the beans and I went in and grabbed a cup and cleaned them. It was too good! Thanks - 9/11/11


  • no profile photo

    Good
    1 of 4 people found this review helpful
    Using mashed celeriac and swede instead of potatoes, (or a mixture of the three) lowers calories, boosts veg intake and tastes really good. - 9/11/11


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    1 of 1 people found this review helpful
    The egg yolk helps the consistency of the mashed potatoes. We made this and it was wonderful. We had to do a few substitutions, so something wasn't -quite- right, but it was still scrumdidilliumptious! - 3/24/11


  • no profile photo


    1 of 2 people found this review helpful
    I love Shepard's Pie I think I will try the veggie option. - 3/24/11


  • no profile photo


    1 of 5 people found this review helpful
    Why the egg yolk in the mashed potatoes? - 3/24/11


  • no profile photo


    I agree with comments below. All measurements should be in grams (unless liquids) so more precise measures can be created. My cottage pie came out at about 350 cal, but that's because I increased the vegies and potato - 5/31/21


  • no profile photo


    I love making this! - 5/31/21


  • no profile photo


    :) - 1/19/21


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    Minor modifications but great flavor! - 12/25/20


  • no profile photo

    Good
    Ok - 12/25/20


  • no profile photo


    Delicious. - 12/24/20


  • no profile photo


    Looks interesting. - 4/2/20


  • no profile photo


    Looks great! - 12/30/19


  • no profile photo


    I would add more veggies like mushrooms and broccoli and spinach and cauliflower and peas.... eat the rainbow,,, - 12/25/19


  • no profile photo

    Good
    I used peas in place of beans. I used taco seasoning in place of chili powder.. I did add a bit potato flakes to thicken, I did not add an egg yolk, I mashed the potatoes added chicken broth with garlic powder salt and pepper and parsley with a bit of paprika and made a second time with grd Turkey - 12/18/19


  • no profile photo


    very tasty - 12/12/19


  • no profile photo


    Nice recipe - 11/24/19


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    A recipe definitely in need of tweaking. As is, didn't care for. - 11/7/19


  • no profile photo


    tasty - 11/3/19


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    YUM! Instead of the egg yolk, I used yogurt with the potatoes and cut the amount of broth used. Otherwise, I followed the recipe. - 10/18/19


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    So tasty! - 5/9/19


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    I make a double on this recipe for the filling and then freeze half for a later pie. All I have to do is make the potatoe topping - 4/12/19


  • no profile photo


    Great idea but will take note of the other suggestions - 4/6/19


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    So Delicious......................Thank You. - 4/4/19


  • no profile photo


    YUM YUM - 4/4/19


  • no profile photo


    Will try - 4/4/19


  • no profile photo


    almost like a shepherd pie - 1/17/19


  • no profile photo


    Absolutely - 1/16/19


  • no profile photo


    The pictures always make everything look so delicious! - 1/11/19


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    Chili powder? Not really authentic. Garlic powder maybe.. half of BEEF stock, homemade, not fake chicken or vegetable broth. IT is supposed to be authentic. - 12/29/18


  • no profile photo


    Yummy and so easy to make. - 12/29/18


  • no profile photo


    like this. thank - 12/14/18


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    This was pretty good. Tasty and filling. - 11/9/18


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    We loved this - 11/6/18


  • no profile photo


    yumm, works with chickent also - 10/31/18


  • no profile photo


    This was really delicious!!! - 10/31/18


  • no profile photo


    Yum! - 10/16/18


  • no profile photo

    Good
    I altered it a pit with Thursday nights marinaded Salmon Roll. Marinade made of Sweet Pepprekia, Fish Sauce, & finely ground cooked Lima Beans. NO MEAT. It could have been 4 stars otherwise.

    Why not learn to enjoy the little things of the wood, the Lord gave us so many of them. - Saint Kateri
    - 4/7/18


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    We like this as lamb is not one of our meats that we eat. This is closer to our down home cooking we go for. - 1/27/18


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    very good - 1/6/18


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    It had a different taste. - 12/16/17


  • no profile photo


    Yum - 12/11/17


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    Thanks for sharing - 11/24/17


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Thanks for sharing this recipe. I made Shepherd's pie before, but this was much better tasting. This will replace my other one. - 11/23/17


  • no profile photo


    I like doing this in the crockpot and then dishing it out to be frozen if I want. - 11/23/17


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Love it! - 11/7/17


  • no profile photo


    looks good - 10/28/17


  • no profile photo


    I can't wait to try this, I have made something like this in the past. - 10/28/17


  • no profile photo


    Delicious - 10/17/17


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    left out the egg in the potatoes - 10/17/17


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    Very tasty!! I shall make this again! - 10/17/17


  • no profile photo


    Slimmed down shepherd's pie. - 10/17/17


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Love this! I used black pepper and a little cayenne instead of the chili, and I replaced half the ground beef with ground turkey. - 11/29/16


  • no profile photo


    In Oz, we use cooked, minced mutton, so cook beef till tender and thicken with a Tbsp of flour. No chili, just peper and a pinch of sage and basil. Corn is not traditional, maybe celery or turnip. Bon appetit! - 4/10/16


  • no profile photo


    What size casserole dish?
    - 1/11/16


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    a little bland will add more spice next time - 6/9/15


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    I have used instant potato flakes for the topping. Works well. - 12/24/14


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    0 of 2 people found this review helpful
    I made this for dinner last night. It was soooo good. The only changes I made were:
    I added a bit more spices, like oregano, basil, and cumin. I added garlic and celery and I followed I.M.Magic's suggestion to thicken it up so I added 2 T of Arrowroot. DH LOVED it!
    - 7/2/14


  • no profile photo


    Hmm too many ingredients for my taste. I call this a 3-ingredient meal all you really need are 3 main ingredients: potatoes, cream corn, & beef. Then I just add some milk & a tiny bit of butter to the potatoes. Salt or pepper can be added later to taste. I prefer my veggies fresh & on the side. - 1/13/14


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    I often make and usually like Chef Meg's recipes, but putting stock photos of similar dishes is misleading and unworthy of a Spark People. Either the recipes made up are good enough tp be photographed are they aren't. There are no peas in the recipe. - 4/4/13


  • no profile photo


    XOXOXO - 4/4/13


  • no profile photo

    Good
    0 of 1 people found this review helpful
    A frozen bag of mixed vegetables is a quick way to make this recipe. I use chicken or turkey instead of beef. Add a shot of worcestershire sauce (low sodium) for a savory taste. - 4/4/13


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    This was very watery and to me lacking in taste. I've also used a flour or cornflour slurry to thicken the juice to make it more pie like. I like to put in some garlic and onion powder to lift up the taste and always a couple of tsp of Worcester sauce - 4/4/13


  • no profile photo


    My husband liked this and he's pretty fussy. I thought the filling was bland, so I added Worcestershire sauce. It's also very runny, need to use less stock or thicken with flour. - 3/3/13


  • no profile photo

    Bad
    Edible, but extremely bland. Crunchy uncooked veggies are not my favorite, so I let simmer for twice as long, but still too crunchy. Didn't care for the dish at all. - 2/21/13


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    I liked the fresh green beans that were still crunchy after baking. Easy to make and easy to eat! Makes a hearty, filling meal. - 2/3/13


  • no profile photo

    Good
    Found the filling a bit runny. I would add less stock or throw a bit of flour in to thicken the sauce next time. Flavors weren't over the top but okay for an ordinary everyday meal which is what I suppose cottage pie is supposed to be. - 2/3/13


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Great - 2/2/13


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    I thought this was really good, and somehow I missed putting in the tomato paste! Big portion, very filling. Never thought I would ever see corn and potatoes in a "diet" recipe that wasn't soup. Delicious. - 11/29/12


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    Very, very tasty! I would definitely make this again, and my typically anti-health-food husband loved it. :) Very hearty and can satisfy the heartiest appetites for few calories - 8/29/12


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    I was pleasantly surprised with the effect of the egg yolk in the mashed potatoes! The dish was full of flavor and the portions were satisfactory. Thanks! - 5/11/12


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    Easy and good. - 1/26/12


  • no profile photo


    0 of 1 people found this review helpful
    Sounds really good. I'll try it. - 1/19/12


  • no profile photo

    Good
    Left out the chili powder and the taste was still very good and the potato topping was fabulous. But, as others have said, it doesn't have the thickened sauce lots of us expect. Next time I'll add about 1/2 cup more broth mixed with 1 T cornstarch to give it more of a gravy. - 1/8/12


  • no profile photo


    Tasty, but it took close to an hour to prepare, not 20 minutes. - 1/7/12


  • no profile photo

    Incredible!
    had for supper last night!
    my filling was not runny, i think i cooked a little longer. would've loved onions in this except hubby can't eat. was very good a nd filling!
    - 1/7/12


  • no profile photo


    My Mom used to grind the meat - which i am sure is the authentic way to do it. - 1/4/12


  • no profile photo


    0 of 1 people found this review helpful
    This sounds wonderful can not wait to go shopping to buy the ingredients. - 1/4/12


  • no profile photo


    0 of 2 people found this review helpful
    I WAS BORN AND RAISED THERE AND CORN WAS ALWAYS FED TO THE PIGS, I NEVER ATE CORN TILL I CAME TO THE US ALMOST 50 YEARS AGO.
    IN ENGLAND WE TRIED TO LIIMIT STARCHES. NO BREAD ON THE TABLE, NO BREAD AND POTATOES SERVED TOGETHER. MY RULE NOW IS STILL THAT WAY POTATOES AND CORN TOGETHEJUST UPS THE CARB
    - 1/4/12


  • no profile photo

    Very Good
    Wow! This was very good! ==comfort food! - 1/4/12


  • no profile photo

    O.K.
    0 of 1 people found this review helpful
    Skip the chili powder, add some HP sauce and you got Shepherds Pie. I make this a lot. - 1/4/12