Mock Wendy's Frosty

Member Ratings For This Recipe

• CD13345672
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  45 of 47 people found this review helpful
  I tried this a few ways my favorite was to use almond milk and replace the ice with a banana, Just peel slice and freeze the banana It does add flavor but I could not tell it wasn't ice cream
  - 11/30/12
  
  
• GEM521
  
  
  Very Good
  

  43 of 43 people found this review helpful
  I use unsweetened vanilla almond milk (less calories) 1 tbsp pudding mix. and the rest of the ingredients per the recipe. I add 1tbsp of cool whip free before blending (makes it really creamy). I am a choco-holic and this definitely hits the spot! - 3/15/11
  
  
• BDUNCANDIET
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  36 of 36 people found this review helpful
  Nice substitute for the real thing and really low calorie count is a plus. I would recommend only putting 5 or 6 ice cubes. It is a little more like a milkshake and not as thick but I found if I added all of the cubes the flavor wasn't as satisfying. Also, you could add peanutbutter, so worth it! - 1/2/09
  
  
• CD1853891
  
  
  Very Good
  

  23 of 25 people found this review helpful
  Although tasty, it was not as thick as I would have liked. It was better after I put it in my freezer for a few minutes. - 5/26/12
  
  
• JGASKEY
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  23 of 23 people found this review helpful
  Awesome. I only had sugar free vanilla pudding and used that instead with just a little extra cocoa powder for the chocolate, it was awesome! - 11/21/10
  
  
• CD14193394
  
  
  
  

  14 of 34 people found this review helpful
  looks & sounds great but I am trying to get away from splenda and other artificial sweeteners. - 8/25/13
  
  
• KRO-BAR
  
  
  Very Good
  

  14 of 16 people found this review helpful
  What a tastey treat! I made it without the cool whip. Tastes more like pudding than a frosting but it's definitely awesome! Thanks for sharing it :) You're righ--I'll be drinking this even after the weight loss is over. - 6/8/08
  
  
• GALINAZ
  
  
  
  

  10 of 26 people found this review helpful
  It seems to defeat the purpose to modify the recipe as many have described, resulting in much higher calories. - 8/25/13
  
  
• TADPOLE17
  
  
  
  

  8 of 16 people found this review helpful
  I would try it with just cocoa powder, vanilla, stevia or (gasp!) a little sugar. No pudding mix, cool-whip, just pure chocolatey goodness. Or try adding non-fat yogurt to add some body. - 8/25/13
  
  
• STARRYNYGHT85
  
  
  Very Good
  

  7 of 9 people found this review helpful
  I changed this up a bit because I try to stay away from the fake sweeteners as much as I can. Muscle Milk Chocolate powder has more good stuff than bad, so I used 1 scoop of that, plus whole milk instead of skim and extra cocoa powder. I also subbed stevia for splenda and added a banana. Tasty! - 6/13/14
  
  
• CD13827513
  
  
  Very Good
  

  7 of 12 people found this review helpful
  There were three of us so I trippled the recipe, used an entire box of SF pudding mix, a combo of Mocha Mix (lactose intolerant) and a little heavy whipping cream, instead of milk, cap of good vanilla, and 3 instant Starbucks coffee packets. YUM!!! It was like a frosty-frappe! Kids LOVED it!!! - 4/7/13
  
  
• SUSAN_TUCKER
  
  
  
  

  6 of 6 people found this review helpful
  I used caramel pudding and it was delicious! - 8/25/13
  
  
• MBEEMOM
  
  
  
  

  5 of 10 people found this review helpful
  You could substitute Splenda containing product with a Stevia containing product couldn't you? I mean really folks! Use your imagination and tweak it a bit to contain less processed ingredients if that is what you aim for. If it works well, please post the recipe to share. - 1/20/14
  
  
• LISA1129
  
  
  
  

  5 of 5 people found this review helpful
  Made as listed, very, very good. I plan to use almond milk and strong coffee next time, in place of the milk. It was plenty sweet for me with 2 packets of Splenda, so may adjust that, but my husband loved it as I made it. - 8/25/13
  
  
• CD12501899
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  4 of 5 people found this review helpful
  YUM! I didn't have cool whip so I used whipping cream (whipped it first) and I also used chocolate almond silk milk. Used my nutribullet to whip it up (precrushed the ice first in a ziplock - hit it a few times with the rolling pin). Split the drink with my girlfriend. Fantabulous! - 8/25/13
  
  
• XRAYLADY65
  
  
  
  

  3 of 8 people found this review helpful
  has anyone tried putting protein powder in this - 3/12/13
  
  
• OSDOWNS
  
  
  Very Good
  

  2 of 2 people found this review helpful
  Yummy! I did find it a bit sweet with both cool whip and Splenda. I will not use Splenda next time. Thanks for the recipe! My family loved it! - 2/24/15
  
  
• CD11902148
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  2 of 3 people found this review helpful
  Pretty darn delicious. My blender couldn't break down my ice cubes completely. May have to smash em up a bit first. Added 1/2 a banana. Very thick and rich tasting. Used almond milk. - 8/25/13
  
  
• MARYELLEN301
  
  
  Very Good
  

  2 of 2 people found this review helpful
  Very chocolaty indeed, but I made half a recipe and it was nowhere near 10 ounces. I used 3 crescent shaped ice cubes. Hardly even a Junior Frosty size, but very tasty. - 2/5/12
  
  
• PAMMYLBEAR
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 1 people found this review helpful
  I enjoyed this! My son told me it wasn't a Frosty if I could drink it. I don't care! It takes care of my chocolate craving . - 3/19/18
  
  
• CD5807913
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 1 people found this review helpful
  I make a Peanut Butter Cheesecake version by replacing the cocoa with PB2 and the chocolate pudding with cheesecake pudding --- LOVE it too! - 4/26/16
  
  
• FOXYPETEY
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 1 people found this review helpful
  Amazing...made with 1/2 cup of fat free milk, 1/2 cup of vanilla almond milk. Also add 1/2 tsp of instant decaf coffee...tasted So GOOD!! - 12/3/15
  
  
• TWITCHYMURDOCH
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 1 people found this review helpful
  I love this recipe and have been making it almost daily. I discovered that some small changes adding very few calories make incredible results! I use 5 or 6 ice cubes, and instead of vanilla, I add almond and coconut extract and some unsweetened toasted coconut flakes. Delecious! - 12/3/15
  
  
• CD15242549
  
  
  
  

  1 of 3 people found this review helpful
  Sounds good. - 2/23/15
  
  
• WILEYTJ
  
  
  O.K.
  

  1 of 1 people found this review helpful
  Used my Nutribullet to make this. It came out grainy and very runny. Will try again using my smoothy maker and maybe less chocolate and ice. The cool whip calories are not included in the full nutritional breakdown so I'm assuming the cool whip is optional for on top of the drink and not in it? - 8/25/13
  
  
• CLAIREGROVER
  
  
  
  

  1 of 6 people found this review helpful
  Sounds yum. Just what I'm looking for. - 10/9/12
  
  
• ITCOML
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 5 people found this review helpful
  I cannot wait to make this i love frostys - 10/3/09
  
  
• ***DEBRA***
  
  
  Incredible!
  

  1 of 5 people found this review helpful
  I'll be making this for sure. - 6/21/08
  
  
• PATRICIAAK
  
  
  
  
  :) - 6/16/21
  
  
• GOFORGIN
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Ok - 6/16/21
  
  
• MMEDFOR1
  
  
  
  
  sounds yummy - 6/3/21
  
  
• MDOWER1
  
  
  
  
  thanks - 5/10/21
  
  
• CORVETTECOWBOY
  
  
  
  
  looks good - 5/2/21
  
  
• HUSKERFAN4EVER
  
  
  
  
  - 4/19/21
  
  
• EOWYN2424
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  yum
  - 4/13/21
  
  
• CD17663415
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  ;-) - 4/9/21
  
  
• LOSER05
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  yum - 4/9/21
  
  
• JULIJULINN
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  7 ice cubes is too many.......use 3-4. - 3/8/21
  
  
• ETHELMERZ
  
  
  O.K.
  
  Ok - 1/19/21
  
  
• NJH1226
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Great just the way it was
  - 1/9/21
  
  
• SHAKERATTLEROLL
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Very good. Enjoyed this while reading a book. Thank you for posting this. - 1/7/21
  
  
• NANASUEH
  
  
  
  
  yummy - 12/5/20
  
  
• EVIE4NOW
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  loved it - 11/16/20
  
  
• TERMITEMOM
  
  
  Good
  
  Nice low cal treat. - 11/10/20
  
  
• REGILIEH
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  YUMMY - 10/21/20
  
  
• CD26260392
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  yummy - 9/16/20
  
  
• JOAN542
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  This recipe is great !!!! Thanks for sharing, my husband and I love it. It's only 65 calories. - 8/22/20
  
  
• CD2693807
  
  
  
  
  instead of ice, try freezing milk in ice cube trays and add slowly in blender... makes for thicker frosty instead of watered down version - 8/13/20
  
  
• TWOTONTESEE
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  I use unsweetened vanilla almond beverage and lite cool whip. This is my go-to when I have a sweet attack and it does the trick. - 6/2/20
  
  
• LAURALLANCE
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Great chocolatey goodness! I skip the cow's milk and use unsweetened vanilla almond milk or coconut milk - so delicious. I've also added frozen cherries. Once in a while we toss in a little cinnamon for an added kick. - 4/26/20
  
  
• REDROBIN47
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  I made this for DH and myself. We both enjoyed it. I will make this for us this summer when it gets hot out. - 4/15/20
  
  
• MOMMY445
  
  
  Good
  
  Good - 3/31/20
  
  
• NEPTUNE1939
  
  
  Very Good
  
  tasty - 3/8/20
  
  
• CD4114015
  
  
  
  
  Great - 1/3/20
  
  
• JANIEWWJD
  
  
  
  
  This was, oh, soooo delicious!!! - 11/12/19
  
  
• SNUZYQ2
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Delicious shake! I ran out of the chocolate pudding, so I substituted the white chocolate flavor. I used 1% milk instead of the fat-free and I added 2 tablespoons of CoffeeMate Sweet Italian Cream in place of the optional Cool Whip. My husband, who is a Wendy's frostie affectionado loved it!! - 11/5/19
  
  
• GRANNYOF05
  
  
  
  
  Sounds delicious - 10/25/19
  
  
• TOMATOCAFEGAL
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Not much cheaper when they are on sale!! - 10/23/19
  
  
• FISHGUT3
  
  
  
  
  thanks - 10/15/19
  
  
• CATWMNCAT
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Excellent! - 10/7/19
  
  
• CECTARR
  
  
  
  
  Thanks - 9/24/19
  
  
• RYCGIRL
  
  
  
  
  love it - 8/4/19
  
  
• WORKOUTLADY1987
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  My husband can't have dairy, so I substituted Almond milk for regular milk and he absolutely loved it which says something since he's really picky about what he eats that is dairy free substitute like ice cream without dairy. - 6/15/19
  
  
• BONNIE1552
  
  
  
  
  Gotta love the lower calories. - 6/11/19
  
  
• ALEPEQUIJADA
  
  
  
  
  Yummy! - 5/31/19
  
  
• RHOOK20047
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Great substitute for a tasty treat. I used other's suggestion using almond milk and fewer ice cubes and loved it!! - 5/18/19
  
  
• MWHIGGINS
  
  
  
  
  I'll be making this for my wife.... she loves Frosties and she is an attractive container... These will help her stay that way - 5/8/19
  
  
• BLAZINGPHOENIX
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Added a Stok shot to this for a caffeine kick and it was awesome!!! - 5/2/19
  
  
• ROBBIEY
  
  
  
  
  Definitely one to try. - 3/5/19
  
  
• LITTLEWIND53
  
  
  
  
  Wow. This sounds yummy. Putting these ingredients on my next shopping list. - 3/1/19
  
  
• DEE107
  
  
  
  
  looks good - 2/16/19
  
  
• CD2951484
  
  
  
  
  This would be good with some protein powder for breakfast - 1/25/19
  
  
• RO2BENT
  
  
  
  
  Nope to artificial sweeteners - 1/18/19
  
  
• AJB121299
  
  
  
  
  nice - 12/29/18
  
  
• SRIVERS1
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  This was really good. Love making this. - 12/20/18
  
  
• MNABOY
  
  
  Good
  
  Thanks for sharing! - 11/30/18
  
  
• ARTJAC
  
  
  
  
  NICE - 11/8/18
  
  
• ELRIDDICK
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Thanks for sharing - 11/8/18
  
  
• CSTINO1
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  I made this tonight for me and my husband and we thought it was great. I did omit adding a sweetener and it was sweet enough! - 10/31/18
  
  
• CD1987279
  
  
  
  
  very tasty - 10/28/18
  
  
• PATRICIAANN46
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  Very Good............. - 10/2/18
  
  
• SEANASHMOM
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Delicious when I want some ice cream without all the calories! - 9/13/18
  
  
• NANAW12001
  
  
  Incredible!
  
  A great dessert. I always use Stevia. - 8/10/18
  
  
• MBPP50
  
  
  
  
  Delicious - 8/9/18
  
  
• PATRICIA-CR
  
  
  
  
  So very yummy. - 7/17/18
  
  
• SHOAPIE
  
  
  
  
  Made mine with unsweetened almond milk. Satisfying. - 7/9/18
  
  
• ROSSYFLOSSY
  
  
  Very Good
  
  Pretty close to the real thing! - 7/2/18
  
  
• JAZZBABY56
  
  
  
  
  What a great find! I can handle lots of stuff but NEED ice cream substitutes. Thanks for sharing. - 6/29/18
  
  
• HOTPINKCAMARO49
  
  
  
  
  Yummy! - 6/23/18
  
  
• BONDMANUS2002
  
  
  
  
  Interesting to - 6/23/18
  
  
• JOHNMARTINMILES
  
  
  
  
  OK Frostys rock! - 6/11/18
  
  
• AZMOMXTWO
  
  
  
  
  thank you - 6/1/18
  
  
• DJ4HEALTH
  
  
  
  
  ok - 5/25/18
  
  
• PWILLOW1
  
  
  
  
  Never thought of using choc. pudding mix in a drink before but I tried this & it was delicious. And at only 68 cal. it will definitely be a keeper. - 5/22/18
  
  
• DMEYER4
  
  
  
  
  yummy - 5/18/18
  
  
• 1CRAZYDOG
  
  
  
  
  Nice! I used banana too instead of the ice. - 5/14/18
  
  
• PICKIE98
  
  
  
  
  Worth trying! - 4/18/18
  
  
• BIKE4HEALTH
  
  
  
  
  what a great treat - 4/8/18
  
  
• DAIZYSTARLITE
  
  
  
  
  yummy - 3/22/18
  
  
• CHERIRIDDELL
  
  
  
  
  delicious ! - 2/28/18